The first month of hard data under the new mortgage rules is in, and the Canadian housing market is cooling faster than many expected. January home sales fell sharply across most major markets, and while some of that decline reflects the pull-forward of buyers into late 2017, the breadth of the slowdown suggests the B-20 stress test is doing exactly what it was designed to do: taking the froth out of demand. This month's report looks at where the cooling is sharpest and what it means for the spring market that traditionally begins in a few weeks.
Bank of Canada (policy rate) and Statistics Canada (inflation).
Sales down, listings mixed
Transaction volumes fell meaningfully year over year in January, with the steepest drops in high-priced regions where uninsured borrowers dominate. New listings have been more muted, which is helping to keep price declines gradual rather than abrupt. When both sales and listings fall together, the market can remain in rough balance even as activity thins out. That is broadly what we are seeing nationally, though the picture varies considerably from city to city.
Toronto and the GTA keep digesting
The Greater Toronto Area continues to work through the correction that began in the spring of 2017. Detached home prices remain well below their early-2017 peak, while condominiums have held up better thanks to their relative affordability. The stress test adds a fresh layer of demand restraint, but the GTA's adjustment is now more about stabilization than fresh decline. Buyers who were priced out during the mania are finding modestly better conditions, even if qualifying for financing has grown harder.
Verified · Jan 1, 2018
OSFI's B-20 stress test began requiring uninsured borrowers to qualify at a higher rate, reducing purchasing power and cooling demand nationwide.
Vancouver softens at the top
In Metro Vancouver, the most expensive detached segment continues to soften while more attainable condos and townhomes remain competitive. British Columbia has signalled additional demand-side measures are coming, which is dampening sentiment at the high end. The combination of stretched affordability, policy uncertainty, and the national stress test makes Vancouver one of the markets most exposed to a prolonged cooling this year.
Bank of Canada policy rate, 2015–2018
Year-end overnight target rate. Source: Bank of Canada.
Montreal quietly gains ground
Montreal is emerging as the counter-narrative. Sales and prices there continue to rise at a healthy, sustainable pace, supported by a strong local economy, relative affordability, and less exposure to the uninsured-borrower squeeze. Because Montreal never experienced the speculative excess of Toronto or Vancouver, it has less to correct and more room to grow. Expect it to be one of the standout performers of 2018.
Inflation (CPI), 2015–2018
Annual average consumer price inflation. Source: Statistics Canada.
Reading the spring market
The traditional spring buying season will be the real test. If activity fails to rebound in March and April the way it normally does, that will confirm the stress test has structurally lowered demand rather than merely shifting its timing. Buyers should watch inventory closely: a build-up of unsold listings into spring would tilt negotiating power their way, while continued restraint on new listings would keep prices sticky even in a slower market.
Looking ahead
February's data reinforces the theme of a market in transition. The cooling is real, but it is orderly, and the low-listing environment is preventing the kind of disorderly price drops that generate panic. For the months ahead, the key variables are the pace of Bank of Canada rate hikes and whether spring demand materializes. We will keep tracking both, and helping people separate signal from noise as the year's story continues to unfold across Canada's very different regional markets.
This analysis is built on Neighbourly.io — the real estate data API for Canada. Standardized addresses, boundaries, demographics, permits and market signals through a single interface.
Explore the data